|
Commercial and recreational fishermen, fishery managers, environmentalists, and academics all have differing opinions regarding the appropriateness and effectiveness of various restructuring tools. Differences on the subject of Individual Fishing Quotas (IFQs) are, perhaps, the most contentious of all. We asked major players on all sides of the issue to share their perspective on IFQs, including their opinion on whether the congressionally-imposed moratorium on the development of IFQ programs should be extended in October 2000. The purpose of these essays is to capture the wide range of perspectives on the issue and to promote collaborative and constructive dialogue.
Points of View
Richard Allen, F/V Ocean Pearl, Pt. Judith, RI
Transferable Fishing Rights are Best for Fish and Fishermen
John Bundy, President, Glacier Fish Company
Lessons from the CDQ Program for Quota-Based Management
Penelope D. Dalton, Assistant Administrator for Fisheries, National Marine Fisheries Service
National Marine Fisheries Position on Individual Fishing Quotas
Dave Fraser, Captain, F/V Muir Milach, Port Townsend, WA
The Benefits of Rights-Based Fishing Cooperatives in the Pollock Fishery
Arne Fuglvog, President, Petersburg Vessel Owners
The Positive Benefits of the Halibut and Sablefish IFQ Program
Rod Fujita, Marine Ecologist, Environmental Defense
The Moratorium on Individual Transferable Quotas Should Be Lifted
Mike Hagler, Oceans Campaign Coordinator, Greenpeace USA
Some Greenpeace Views on ITQs
Rod Moore, Executive Director, West Coast Seafood Processors Association
Sharing the Costs and Benefits
Paul Parker, Executive Director, Cape Cod Commercial Hook Fishermen's Association
Privatization Didn't Work for Rangelands and It Won't Work for New England Fisheries
Jeff Pike, Director, Government Relations, Sher & Blackwell
Quota-Based Programs
Carl Safina, Vice President for Marine Conservation, National Audubon Society
Individual Fishery Quotas: Allocation, Conservation, or Both?
Beth Stewart, Director, Department of Natural Resources, Aleutians East Borough
Style or Substance?
Bob Storrs, Vice President, Unalaska Native Fisherman's Association
Unalaska Locals Are Wary of ITQs
Mike Weber, freelance writer and consultant on marine conservation policy
Obstacles to ITQs
|